With recent conversation about several players, who suggested different roll setup for VW, this made me rethink about applicable rolls in VW for DD pt.
One of the WAR suggested Regain+Chaos, although I do agree that chaos provides bigger boost than few TPs, but regain instead of save TP is big question. Assuming both buffs are both No.11, Misers has 5 times more TP return than one tick regain, that means regain needs 15 sec to catch up to Misers.
Since any WAR with double march can WS way faster than 15 sec/WS in VW, there's no way that Regain can beat misers.
However, what I was wondering is if sacrificing misers for 2nd boost dmg roll like DA or crit is worth it.
It seems with all the wings spam, and how misers can ended up very little TP(thus didn't lower your hit build, like old SAM roll debate) if number is bad, aiming for highest WS dmg may be the way to go.
Then the next question is, DA v.s attack v.s crit-hit roll.
This is obviously very job dependent, very mob dependent too.
SAM and none-Rag DRK barely benefit from crit-hit due to lack of crit-hit WS.
WAR BLU NIN MNK may benefit from crit-hit roll.
According to some parse done by Marquiss, chaos roll increased about 100 CDC avg dmg on Qilin, which isn't a lot. I kinda believe crit-hit roll+DA may have higher WS avg output, at least for CDC. This may apply to Ukko also.
Crit-hit roll may also benefit melee DPS more than chaos, at least for sword(almace).
However for job like SAM and none-rag DRK, DA Chaos may still be the way to go.
That means for optimal result, I need different DD buffs depending on the job.
That also means old roll rotation is back, roll DD A X and Y roll, DD B Y and Z roll, finally myself completely different set of DD rolls....since I don't need DA and crit-hit roll.
At least I'm glad that roll rotation is back. Rolling only 2 rolls is just boring. With newly finished winning streak augment, each roll can stay for nearly 7 min, enough to roll a bunch of different rolls for everyone.
Monday, 6 February 2012
Sunday, 5 February 2012
20 jobs
I do /shout VW pt pretty often, and sometimes I often got /tell asking "what job you need?", if I answered "What job do you have?", I sometimes got "I have almost every job" reply.
I know now with easy +2, easy empy and easy EXP, many ppl have 10 or even 20 jobs 99.
And quite a lot of ppl tend to "look down" on those with 1 job, like it's a huge crime not to have NIN WAR MNK WHM for abyssea, BST DNC THF for dyna, or plays job like PUP etc.
I won't deny that playing only one job is pretty inconvenient most of the time. That a player with variety of job available will have easier life in this game.
However, most of the time that if I got "I have almost every job" reply, I tend to got BLM that has no thundaja because it's "too expensive"and refuse to buy it, no magian staff too. Or WHM with only 20% cure potency. Or empy/relic DDs doing 2%~5% on parse and so on.
One simple fact is, if you have 20 jobs, you can't be good at all of them, even if you have enough time to grind gears for all jobs, there won't be enough inv to fit them all. In fact I only have 2 jobs, and my BLU is gimp as fuck, skipped many pieces for optimal result due to inv issue etc. And I know that my BLU will never be good, it never was, and never will.
I still don't understand why ppl would lv 20 jobs, and asked "what job do you need?" in VW pt, listed them all, when majority of jobs listed are not use-able without proper spell/gear/skill, just to get a pt invite.
Tavera said it's variety, and it's fun to play different jobs. I guess that's probably the main reason. However as this game starting to move out of Abyssea with MORE gear grind, and some design such as 3 limited merit WS, it's clear that having variety of job means you more or less have to sacrifice something.
And I think it's a fair trade. Bandwagon 20 jobs all you want, I'm still gonna ignore your /tell to a B.rex run if you don't have Thundaja.
Hybrid
So someone on AH started a thread named Versatility on BLU in VW on BLU forum. Although the title says about versatility, the thread actually ended up as BLU being a viable DD or not.
Then the entire thread turned into Prothescar claiming BLU is top tier DD in VW, right below WAR but better than MNK, and BLU should go all out DD instead of sit back and proc.
Minjo made an interesting comment in the dicussion:
"BLU isn't versatile. In fact, it's become extremely useful because it's drifted so far from versatility. It went from a hybrid melee-spellcaster that was fairly useless for everything to a very respectable melee job that hardly ever touches the spell list outside of proc situations."
IMO, that actually sum up the situation of any job that wants to fit in end game.
Versatility shines in lowman, but real large scale EG event there aren't much use for hybrids.
DNC, PUP, SCH, BLU, RDM, all those are jobs are hybrid, and not really considered main stream EG job. RDM used to dominate, but not anymore, when it's unique aspect is replaced or not irrelevant. NIN was considered hybrid, but it wasn't revived until Abyssea comes and it's dmg output increased, plus proc and how it's lowman/solo friendly. In fact if there isn't proc I'm going to put my money on the table that you won't see NIN in VW at all.
It seems that hybrid job without main focus just doesn't fit all that into large scale event in this game.
If BLU really become "useful" because it's dmg increase and more DD focus, it will somewhat kill the job for me, since most of the fun I get from playing BLU is lowman.......duo, solo, make use of it's versatility. For me BLU is always a lowman job while COR being my EG job, since lv 75.
I guess in a way, I'm not ready to accept the era of BLU playing all out offensively like a MNK DRK etc.
On the other hand that also means certain job is only useful if one aspect shines.
I have to admit, I'm worry about after save TP nerf COR will go back to the era of "nice to have, but not must have" weak job, due to lack of main focus as a hybrid job, that I may as well just retire it again and focus on DD BLU if I need dmg.
At this point of time, I'd say COR in VW is the golden era of COR, that only once exist long time ago in pink bird merit pt(which isn't EG). Both as a buffer as a DD.
In a DD zerg pt with other melees, I usually parse around 7%~24% in VW alliance. I admit I can't beat good/elite tier melees and RNGs, but average empy WAR/shoha SAM/DRK/relic bow RNG that doesn't know what they're doing, I can win pretty easily.
In B.rex pt, it's anywhere between 20%~39% (highest record), which is slightly higher due to it's weak against magic.
Although still not a top tier DD, I'd still consider it a "DD" job atm, and it's dmg is somewhat relevant.
Compare with 75 era, COR dmg output in an alliance is about 1%~3%. This is based on Einherjar parse with Sinister. Tigerfury, the best COR I know of at 75 and a player I learned a lot about this job from, barely break 5% in entire alliance, and he was doing at least more dmg than a THF.
COR has a bit higher output in pink bird merit pt due to birds weak against piercing, plus they have lower evasion. Therefore it has somewhat relevant output in pink bird pt. But in real 75 EG event like Einherjar it hardly make a difference......weak acc, low combat skill, it's such a killer for anyone who wants to play offensively.
In terms of support, DD buff it's hardly as game breaking as BRD double march. Chaos is good, however fighters won't cut it compare with march.
In fact even chaos is questionable on T3.....Marquiss's parse shows only 100 dmg increase with chaos on Qilin.
That made the job a hybrid, with 2 different aspect, but none of the aspect makes a huge difference.
At this point of time, buff of this job makes bigger difference than 75 era fighter, save TP is so powerful that SE actually wanted to nerf it. It's dmg is also a lot more relevant than 75.....I parsed anywhere from No.4~No.1 with other melees and RNGs depending on situation, this never happened at 75.
I used to duo/trio dyna on BLU, after I lv COR to 99 and learned Misers I started to duo/trio on COR only. My COR's dmg certainly beats my BLU atm(since my BLU gimp anyways), and it's TP buff actually benefits other pt member greatly, that I had way better result and killing speed on COR than BLU. In fact I ended up using COR for everything including lowman ZNM just because it's dmg, plus dmg added to pt member, easily made it worth while. This never happen in my whole life, after 2.5 years of play this job and main it.
After save TP nerf I expect the dmg of this job will drop a lot being WS spike dmg job and fairly weak and slow during TP phrase, everyone will drop dmg, but COR will drop more than every other DD. Beating up average melees on parse probably not gonna happen anymore. It will go back to the dark era of dmg output not being relevant again.
Long time ago I already stated that unless hybrid has one aspect that's strong enough to make a game changing difference, it will never get a place. DNC is a pretty good DD even outside of abby, but it never get invited as a DD in VW. So does SCH and PUP, they never got invite as a nuker, or DD, or healer. RDM and BLU only got invited to VW as a proc whore that's it.
And that's probably why those BLU mains tried so hard to made BLU into a DD focused job, to make it have a relevant spot in EG.
I have to admit, after I revived COR for VW, I enjoyed the job a lot, for 1.5 months. I never had a job that can WS this much, and kill this fast with a pt. I never had the luxury of reaching on top of the parse in EG and epeen this much in my whole life. My buffs never made such a noticeable difference. Misers roll, 2 hit WS back to back, self skill chain with double QD and misers in dyna, spam waltz 3 like no tomorrow and never die.........I never seen so many CORs on the street, with everyone and their mother lving it. And I'm happy, I was quite lonely in this game to play a least played job in this game, but VW made it bandwagon, now I have a lot more companions, and more ppl to talk about the job.
Now it's all like a dream in the past.
Except, this dream is so short, sweet and short.
After I tasted sweet dream, I'm unable to go back again.
I remember ppl always jelly if I somehow top the parse, or tried to deal decent dmg.
At lv 75 one RNG told me I'm a gambler, not a DD.
In VW era Returner told me the same, says something like it isn't fair for a buffer to do this much dmg.
For many ppl, COR doing DD tier dmg is just wrong and needs to be fixed.
Now the fix is here, by next update I'm going to put my money on the table that an elite tier BRD/DNC singing march x2 and swinging Mandau spamming Exe duoing with a THF/DNC will kill way faster than elite tier COR/DNC using w/e DD roll it has, swinging Qilin dagger spamming WF/last stand duoing with a THF.
So what's the point to even bring the job to dyna, nyzul, salvage etc? Except doing attack buff whore in Legion and VW, so DRK WAR RNG can epeen more.
I guess time to continue to finish Almace for my BLU, and just screw COR for now, so I will have a job that doesn't gimp on dmg and able to kill fast. Once again, I feel all my effort on gear grind is wasted.....all this years I tried to prove that COR can DD too, and able to excel in every event every aspect, only to have SE take it away and make it impossible again.
Maybe I picked the wrong job to begin with, for many reason I feel I will have a happier life if I picked BRD as my main 2.5 years ago.
Then the entire thread turned into Prothescar claiming BLU is top tier DD in VW, right below WAR but better than MNK, and BLU should go all out DD instead of sit back and proc.
Minjo made an interesting comment in the dicussion:
"BLU isn't versatile. In fact, it's become extremely useful because it's drifted so far from versatility. It went from a hybrid melee-spellcaster that was fairly useless for everything to a very respectable melee job that hardly ever touches the spell list outside of proc situations."
IMO, that actually sum up the situation of any job that wants to fit in end game.
Versatility shines in lowman, but real large scale EG event there aren't much use for hybrids.
DNC, PUP, SCH, BLU, RDM, all those are jobs are hybrid, and not really considered main stream EG job. RDM used to dominate, but not anymore, when it's unique aspect is replaced or not irrelevant. NIN was considered hybrid, but it wasn't revived until Abyssea comes and it's dmg output increased, plus proc and how it's lowman/solo friendly. In fact if there isn't proc I'm going to put my money on the table that you won't see NIN in VW at all.
It seems that hybrid job without main focus just doesn't fit all that into large scale event in this game.
If BLU really become "useful" because it's dmg increase and more DD focus, it will somewhat kill the job for me, since most of the fun I get from playing BLU is lowman.......duo, solo, make use of it's versatility. For me BLU is always a lowman job while COR being my EG job, since lv 75.
I guess in a way, I'm not ready to accept the era of BLU playing all out offensively like a MNK DRK etc.
On the other hand that also means certain job is only useful if one aspect shines.
I have to admit, I'm worry about after save TP nerf COR will go back to the era of "nice to have, but not must have" weak job, due to lack of main focus as a hybrid job, that I may as well just retire it again and focus on DD BLU if I need dmg.
At this point of time, I'd say COR in VW is the golden era of COR, that only once exist long time ago in pink bird merit pt(which isn't EG). Both as a buffer as a DD.
In a DD zerg pt with other melees, I usually parse around 7%~24% in VW alliance. I admit I can't beat good/elite tier melees and RNGs, but average empy WAR/shoha SAM/DRK/relic bow RNG that doesn't know what they're doing, I can win pretty easily.
In B.rex pt, it's anywhere between 20%~39% (highest record), which is slightly higher due to it's weak against magic.
Although still not a top tier DD, I'd still consider it a "DD" job atm, and it's dmg is somewhat relevant.
Compare with 75 era, COR dmg output in an alliance is about 1%~3%. This is based on Einherjar parse with Sinister. Tigerfury, the best COR I know of at 75 and a player I learned a lot about this job from, barely break 5% in entire alliance, and he was doing at least more dmg than a THF.
COR has a bit higher output in pink bird merit pt due to birds weak against piercing, plus they have lower evasion. Therefore it has somewhat relevant output in pink bird pt. But in real 75 EG event like Einherjar it hardly make a difference......weak acc, low combat skill, it's such a killer for anyone who wants to play offensively.
In terms of support, DD buff it's hardly as game breaking as BRD double march. Chaos is good, however fighters won't cut it compare with march.
In fact even chaos is questionable on T3.....Marquiss's parse shows only 100 dmg increase with chaos on Qilin.
That made the job a hybrid, with 2 different aspect, but none of the aspect makes a huge difference.
At this point of time, buff of this job makes bigger difference than 75 era fighter, save TP is so powerful that SE actually wanted to nerf it. It's dmg is also a lot more relevant than 75.....I parsed anywhere from No.4~No.1 with other melees and RNGs depending on situation, this never happened at 75.
I used to duo/trio dyna on BLU, after I lv COR to 99 and learned Misers I started to duo/trio on COR only. My COR's dmg certainly beats my BLU atm(since my BLU gimp anyways), and it's TP buff actually benefits other pt member greatly, that I had way better result and killing speed on COR than BLU. In fact I ended up using COR for everything including lowman ZNM just because it's dmg, plus dmg added to pt member, easily made it worth while. This never happen in my whole life, after 2.5 years of play this job and main it.
After save TP nerf I expect the dmg of this job will drop a lot being WS spike dmg job and fairly weak and slow during TP phrase, everyone will drop dmg, but COR will drop more than every other DD. Beating up average melees on parse probably not gonna happen anymore. It will go back to the dark era of dmg output not being relevant again.
Long time ago I already stated that unless hybrid has one aspect that's strong enough to make a game changing difference, it will never get a place. DNC is a pretty good DD even outside of abby, but it never get invited as a DD in VW. So does SCH and PUP, they never got invite as a nuker, or DD, or healer. RDM and BLU only got invited to VW as a proc whore that's it.
And that's probably why those BLU mains tried so hard to made BLU into a DD focused job, to make it have a relevant spot in EG.
I have to admit, after I revived COR for VW, I enjoyed the job a lot, for 1.5 months. I never had a job that can WS this much, and kill this fast with a pt. I never had the luxury of reaching on top of the parse in EG and epeen this much in my whole life. My buffs never made such a noticeable difference. Misers roll, 2 hit WS back to back, self skill chain with double QD and misers in dyna, spam waltz 3 like no tomorrow and never die.........I never seen so many CORs on the street, with everyone and their mother lving it. And I'm happy, I was quite lonely in this game to play a least played job in this game, but VW made it bandwagon, now I have a lot more companions, and more ppl to talk about the job.
Now it's all like a dream in the past.
Except, this dream is so short, sweet and short.
After I tasted sweet dream, I'm unable to go back again.
I remember ppl always jelly if I somehow top the parse, or tried to deal decent dmg.
At lv 75 one RNG told me I'm a gambler, not a DD.
In VW era Returner told me the same, says something like it isn't fair for a buffer to do this much dmg.
For many ppl, COR doing DD tier dmg is just wrong and needs to be fixed.
Now the fix is here, by next update I'm going to put my money on the table that an elite tier BRD/DNC singing march x2 and swinging Mandau spamming Exe duoing with a THF/DNC will kill way faster than elite tier COR/DNC using w/e DD roll it has, swinging Qilin dagger spamming WF/last stand duoing with a THF.
So what's the point to even bring the job to dyna, nyzul, salvage etc? Except doing attack buff whore in Legion and VW, so DRK WAR RNG can epeen more.
I guess time to continue to finish Almace for my BLU, and just screw COR for now, so I will have a job that doesn't gimp on dmg and able to kill fast. Once again, I feel all my effort on gear grind is wasted.....all this years I tried to prove that COR can DD too, and able to excel in every event every aspect, only to have SE take it away and make it impossible again.
Maybe I picked the wrong job to begin with, for many reason I feel I will have a happier life if I picked BRD as my main 2.5 years ago.
Friday, 3 February 2012
Nerf Hammer
SE:WAR MNK nerf
Afania: Mwhahahah now no more bandwagon WAR MNK and epeen with their empy WS mwhahaha. Now go lv jobs you love instead of bandwagon the strongest k? NO ONE LAUGH AT ME FOR NOT BANDWAGONING DD JOB.
SE:BST TH nerf
Afania: Mwhahahah now no more BST only in dyna BS, go lv jobs you love instead of bandwagon BST k? NO ONE LAUGH AT ME FOR NOT HAVING BST IN DYNA.
SE:Save TP nerf:
Afania:
My dream of beating up melees and RNGs in Qilin challenge is over ;(
Afania: Mwhahahah now no more bandwagon WAR MNK and epeen with their empy WS mwhahaha. Now go lv jobs you love instead of bandwagon the strongest k? NO ONE LAUGH AT ME FOR NOT BANDWAGONING DD JOB.
SE:BST TH nerf
Afania: Mwhahahah now no more BST only in dyna BS, go lv jobs you love instead of bandwagon BST k? NO ONE LAUGH AT ME FOR NOT HAVING BST IN DYNA.
SE:Save TP nerf:
Afania:
My dream of beating up melees and RNGs in Qilin challenge is over ;(
Thursday, 2 February 2012
Need new SJ
In one of the B.rex run I happened to pt with Blueskysapphire, a pimp JP RNG. After some parses and some discussion about gears with him (he has COR too), it seems that /BLM will do more dmg than /RDM.
According to him, he has 103 base AGI with /BLM. I have 100 with /RDM. We're both hume F, with 12/12 AGI merit. I also asked him to change to /RDM and confirmed that /BLM does give 3 extra AGI than /RDM.
This makes /BLM probably the strongest SJ for WF CORs. Can get access to stun too, which is useful in fights like B.rex when you do need stun. Although losing plenty of support ability from /RDM like MDB, SS, Phalanx, cure, raise and refresh.
This makes me wonder if /BLU is better at this lv too.
I've tested /BLU v.s /RDM at lv 90, however at lv 99 /BLU gains 3 extra AGI compare with 90. Now /BLU has 11 extra AGI compare with /RDM, but only losing 4 MAB.
Following the rule of 2 AGI > 1 MAB, 11 AGI should beat 4 MAB.
Compare with /BLM, it's 8 AGI v.s 4 MAB. So it's pretty much equal, or a little bit better/worse. But /BLM has way more useful spell (stun and D2), while /BLU doesn't offer much useful spell besides lol Metallic body and cocoon.
Also /BLU can set a bit more HP boost spell for survive-ability I guess. After I lowered my HP merit I realized the impact of low HP is bigger than I thought......Seriously considering just screw my dream of playing COR like fake BRD and get my HP back ;(
On paper /BLU should beat /RDM, probably gonna test it soonish to make sure it's 100% better than /RDM, then I'll /BLU for WF in VW then.
Until I finish lving /BLM ;(
I really don't like to lv BLM, one of my least favorite job(besides MNK) ;(
According to him, he has 103 base AGI with /BLM. I have 100 with /RDM. We're both hume F, with 12/12 AGI merit. I also asked him to change to /RDM and confirmed that /BLM does give 3 extra AGI than /RDM.
This makes /BLM probably the strongest SJ for WF CORs. Can get access to stun too, which is useful in fights like B.rex when you do need stun. Although losing plenty of support ability from /RDM like MDB, SS, Phalanx, cure, raise and refresh.
This makes me wonder if /BLU is better at this lv too.
I've tested /BLU v.s /RDM at lv 90, however at lv 99 /BLU gains 3 extra AGI compare with 90. Now /BLU has 11 extra AGI compare with /RDM, but only losing 4 MAB.
Following the rule of 2 AGI > 1 MAB, 11 AGI should beat 4 MAB.
Compare with /BLM, it's 8 AGI v.s 4 MAB. So it's pretty much equal, or a little bit better/worse. But /BLM has way more useful spell (stun and D2), while /BLU doesn't offer much useful spell besides lol Metallic body and cocoon.
Also /BLU can set a bit more HP boost spell for survive-ability I guess. After I lowered my HP merit I realized the impact of low HP is bigger than I thought......Seriously considering just screw my dream of playing COR like fake BRD and get my HP back ;(
On paper /BLU should beat /RDM, probably gonna test it soonish to make sure it's 100% better than /RDM, then I'll /BLU for WF in VW then.
Until I finish lving /BLM ;(
I really don't like to lv BLM, one of my least favorite job(besides MNK) ;(
Monday, 30 January 2012
Exenterator
After A LOT of flan spam, I managed to finish Exenterator merit, and put a gimp set together.
P.S Belt is Crudelis belt.
Missing AGI+13 head (which I'm not going to buy unless Toci drop), AGI+4 or Aesir earring(which I should work on it soon), Athos body(which is 0/55) or Denali body.
Played it a bit in dyna, it's actually stronger than I expected, around 1.2k~1.5k on EP fish with no food. Depending on mob type and whether fire shot is up, it could be stronger than WF, but generally weaker than Last Stand.
Obviously this is my "cheap WS", considering Last Stand uses 2 bullets, every time when I use it my heart bleeds and I can hear my wallet screaming.
Or I can use some excuses: "But.....but Exenterator has acc-!"
But yeah, besides saving gil and -acc, there are no reason to use it over Last Stand.
Now all 3 merit WS done, time to finish MP merit.
P.S Belt is Crudelis belt.
Missing AGI+13 head (which I'm not going to buy unless Toci drop), AGI+4 or Aesir earring(which I should work on it soon), Athos body(which is 0/55) or Denali body.
Played it a bit in dyna, it's actually stronger than I expected, around 1.2k~1.5k on EP fish with no food. Depending on mob type and whether fire shot is up, it could be stronger than WF, but generally weaker than Last Stand.
Obviously this is my "cheap WS", considering Last Stand uses 2 bullets, every time when I use it my heart bleeds and I can hear my wallet screaming.
Or I can use some excuses: "But.....but Exenterator has acc-!"
But yeah, besides saving gil and -acc, there are no reason to use it over Last Stand.
Now all 3 merit WS done, time to finish MP merit.
20%!
After some grinding and bugging ppl to sell alex to me(since there are 10000 rich ppl buying all the alex available), finally break 6k mark on alex, which is 20%.
5 more years and I can finish, I know it!
5 more years and I can finish, I know it!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)